Crisis Studies of the Islamic World

Crisis Studies of the Islamic World

Publication Ethics

Ethical Principles of Publishing Articles in the Journals of Crisis Studies of the Islamic World" (CSIW)

 

The Crisis Studies of the Islamic World iournal (CSIW) is committed to publishing and disseminating high-quality research. Our editorial operations are governed by rigorous, transparent, and fair ethical standards. We expect all participants in the publishing process—editors, authors, reviewers, and the publisher—to understand and adhere to these policies. Our standards are aligned with the Core Practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), available at: COPE Core Practices.

By submitting an article to CSIW, you agree to comply with this statement

          1-Responsibility of the Author

  • Reporting Standards
    Authors of original research must present an accurate account of the work performed and an objective discussion of its significance. Underlying data must be represented accurately in the manuscript. The article should contain sufficient detail and references to allow others to replicate the work. Fraudulent or knowingly inaccurate statements constitute unethical behavior and are unacceptable.
  • Data Access and Retention
    Authors may be required to provide the raw data supporting their manuscript for editorial review and must be prepared to make this data publicly available if practicable. Authors should ensure that data remains accessible to other competent professionals for at least ten years after publication, preferably via an institutional or subject-based data repository. This is contingent on the confidentiality of participants being protected and no legal rights concerning proprietary data being violated.
  • Originality and Plagiarism
    Authors must submit only entirely original works and appropriately cite or quote the work and/or words of others. Influential publications that shaped the reported work must be acknowledged.
  • Direct quotations must be placed in quotation marks and cited.
  • The source of all data must be specified.
  • Authors must not submit a manuscript that has been previously submitted to CSIW, assessed, and rejected. In specific situations where a significantly revised version of a rejected manuscript is to be resubmitted, the authors must first contact the editors, clearly explain the changes made, and receive permission to proceed.


Plagiarism takes many forms, including but not limited to:

  • Misattribution of Authorship:Listing individuals as authors who did not contribute to the work, or omitting those who did.
  • Textual Plagiarism:Copying substantial portions of text from another work without attribution, even if the source is the author's own prior work (self-plagiarism).
  • Idea Plagiarism:Presenting the ideas, concepts, or results of others as one's own.
  • Data Fabrication and Falsification:Presenting false or manipulated data as genuine results.
  • Simultaneous Submission:Submitting the same manuscript to multiple journals concurrently.
  • onsequences of Plagiarism and Misconduct


The journal editors will investigate any suspected plagiarism or ethical misconduct. Based on the severity of the violation, consequences may include:

  • Rejection of the manuscript, or retraction of a published article.
  • A ban on future submissions from all involved authors.
  • Notification of the authors' institutions and/or relevant regulatory bodies.
  • Public notification of the malpractice in the journal.
  • Formal communication of the misconduct to other journal editors, databases, and relevant organizations (e.g., the Ministry of Science, Research and Technology).

 

  • Multiple, Redundant, or Concurrent Publication
    Generally, manuscripts describing the same research should not be published in more than one journal. Submitting the same manuscript to multiple journals concurrently constitutes unethical publishing behavior and is unacceptable. Manuscripts that have been published as copyrighted material elsewhere cannot be submitted. Manuscripts under review by CSIWmust not be submitted to other publications until the review process is complete. Exceptions may be made for certain types of creative works; authors should consult the editor in such cases.
  • Acknowledgment of Sources
    Authors must properly acknowledge the work of others. All publications that were influential in the nature of the reported work should be cited. Information obtained privately (e.g., through conversation, correspondence, or discussion with third parties) must not be used without explicit written permission from the source. Information obtained through confidential services, such as refereeing manuscripts or grant applications, must not be used without the explicit written permission of the author of that work.
  • Authorship
    Authorship must be limited to those who have made a significant contribution to the conception, design, execution, or interpretation of the reported study. All significant contributors must be listed as co-authors. Those who have participated in certain substantive aspects of the project should be acknowledged in the 'Contributors' or 'Acknowledgment' section.
  • The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring that all appropriate (and only appropriate) co-authors are included on the paper.
  • All co-authors must review and approve the final version of the manuscript and agree to its submission for publication.
  • All authors share responsibility for the content and results of the article.
  • Faculty members must list the student as the principal author if the article is derived directly from the student's dissertation or thesis.
  • The corresponding author must confirm that all co-authors are satisfied with the manuscript prior to its submission.
  • Disclosure and Conflicts of Interest
    Authors must disclose in their manuscript any financial or other substantive conflicts of interest that could be construed to influence the results or their interpretation. All sources of financial support for the project must be disclosed.Examples of potential conflicts of interest include employment, consultancies, stock ownership, honoraria, paid expert testimony, patent applications/registrations, and grants or other funding. Potential conflicts must be disclosed to the editor at the earliest possible stage. Readers have the right to know who funded the research and what role the funders played.
  • Fundamental Errors in Published Works
    If an author discovers a significant error or inaccuracy in their own published work, it is their obligation to promptly notify the journal editor and cooperate in retracting or correcting the paper. If the editor is notified by a third party of a significant error in a published paper, the author must promptly provide evidence of the paper's correctness or cooperate with the editor to issue a correction or retraction.
  • Double-Blind Peer Review
    CSIWemploys a double-blind peer-review process. This means the identities of both the authors and the reviewers are concealed from each other.

Author Responsibilities:

  • Authors must respect the confidentiality of the process and must not reveal their identity to reviewers.
  • Manuscripts must be prepared to ensure anonymity. Any information that could identify the authors (e.g., in the main text, acknowledgments, or file properties) must be removed prior to submission.
  • Authors must not post their submitted manuscript on personal websites, preprint servers, or social media that would break the blinding for reviewers.
  • Authors must not suggest reviewers whom they know personally or with whom they have a conflict of interest (see below).
  • Conflicts of Interest in Peer Review
    To ensure a fair and unbiased assessment, authors are required to disclose any potential conflicts of interest with editors or reviewers at the time of submission.

Examples of conflicts of interest include:

  • A reviewer being from the same institution or university as one of the authors.
  • A recent (e.g., within the past two years) or current collaborative relationship, such as being co-authors on a publication or members of the same thesis committee.
  • A personal relationship or known strong personal bias.
  • Manuscripts submitted by editors, editorial board members, or reviewers will be handled by an independent editor and reviewed by external referees to avoid any conflict of interest.
  • Precision
    Authors are solely responsible for the entire content of their submitted manuscript. They must present an accurate account of the research performed and an objective discussion of its significance. Findings must be reported thoroughly and transparently, without omitting data relevant to the research questions, whether they support the expected outcomes or not.The manuscript must include sufficient detail and references to allow other researchers to access the same data and replicate the study. Fundamental assumptions, theories, methods, and protocols relevant to the findings must be clearly disclosed. If an author discovers a significant error or inaccuracy in their submitted or published work, they must promptly notify the editor-in-chief and cooperate fully to correct or retract the paper.
  • Ethical Research and Human Rights
    Authors are responsible for ensuring their work complies with ethical standards for research involving human subjects. This includes preserving privacy, ensuring beneficence, and supporting human dignity, freedom, and welfare. Studies involving human participants (e.g., field studies, simulations, interviews) must be conducted in accordance with relevant human rights regulations and institutional ethical guidelines. Proof of ethical approval may be required.
  • Timeliness
    Authors are expected to respond promptly to editorial requests (e.g., for revisions, proofreading). If an author cannot meet a given deadline (typically a maximum of one month), they must immediately contact the editor-in-chief to request an extension or withdraw from the review process. 

 

         2- Responsibility of the Editor

  • The editor's primary responsibility is to decide which submissions to the journal will be published. Editors must ensure that these decisions are based solely on the academic and scientific merit of the manuscript and must not be influenced by the author's race, gender, religious or political beliefs, ethnicity, or citizenship.
  • Confidentiality

Information regarding a submitted manuscript must be kept confidential. The editor may disclose it only to the corresponding author, reviewers, potential reviewers, editorial board members, and the publisher as required or appropriate.

  • Disclosure and Conflicts of Interest

Unpublished materials from a submitted manuscript must not be used in an editor's or reviewer's own research without the author's explicit written consent. Editors and reviewers must recuse themselves from considering manuscripts in which they have conflicts of interest resulting from competitive, collaborative, or other relationships with any of the authors, companies, or institutions connected to the paper. Editors should follow the procedure set out in the COPE flowchart and respond promptly to complaints, ensuring a clear path for complainants to escalate their concerns.

  • Editorial Independence

Editors must preserve the independence of their editorial decisions and ensure that authors are free to express their views. The responsibility for accepting or rejecting a manuscript rests with the editor, informed by the manuscript's scope, originality, and the reviewers' recommendations. Manuscripts that are clearly unsuitable may be rejected without external peer review.

  • Impartiality

Editors must evaluate manuscripts confidentially, constructively, and impartially. The peer review process must be based on scientific merit alone. Editors must act without bias and avoid personal or ideological advocacy.

  • Conflicts of Interest

Editors must avoid actions that create an actual or perceived conflict of interest. For example, an editor must not publish a manuscript that has not been properly identified, reviewed, and selected. To manage potential conflicts, an editor should delegate the review of any manuscript where a conflict exists to a qualified individual, such as a previous editor or a member of the editorial board. Editors must avoid handling manuscripts that conflict with their interests due to competitive, collaborative, financial, or other connections to the authors, companies, or institutions involved.

Examples of relationships that may constitute a conflict of interest include:

  • The author and editor being employed by the same institution.
  • The editor having served on the author’s dissertation committee, or vice versa.
  • The editor and author being current co-workers or having been co-authors within the past two years.

Author Forms: When submitting your article, please ensure all authors have signed and uploaded the following forms:

  • Double-Blind Peer-Review

The journal employs a double-blind peer-review process, meaning the identities of both authors and reviewers are concealed from each other. Assessment standards and reviewer guidelines must be expressed clearly and concisely.

  • Confidentiality in Peer Review(Note: This section consolidates the two previous "Confidentiality" points)

Editors and editorial board members must not disclose any information about a submitted manuscript to anyone other than the corresponding author, reviewers, and publisher. Formal procedures must be in place to preserve the confidentiality of the assessment process. Editors are responsible for safeguarding the double-blind review process and preventing the disclosure of information that could reveal the identities of authors or reviewers. A reviewer's anonymity may be breached only with their explicit permission. Unpublished materials from a submitted manuscript may not be used in an editor's personal research without the author's written consent. Privileged information or ideas obtained through the peer review process must be kept confidential and not used for personal advantage.

  • Assessment Quality

Typically, two reviewers are invited to evaluate each article. The editor is responsible for qualitatively evaluating all reviews. The editor may minimally edit a review before sending it to the author—for example, to remove language that reveals the reviewer’s identity or that is unprofessional. Reviews that are not constructive or appropriate may be withheld entirely.

The quality of reviews, including rankings, scores, and other performance metrics, is periodically assessed by the editor to ensure the optimized operation of the Crisis Studies of the Islamic World Journal ((CSIW). This data informs decisions regarding the reappointment of reviewers and future review assignments. Individual reviewer performance data must remain accessible to editors and kept confidential.

  • Timeliness

To ensure timely article assessment and a rapid response to author inquiries regarding status, editors must perform an initial assessment and select reviewers promptly. Authors should be notified of the assessment status within a determined deadline, ideally no later than one week after manuscript submission.

  • Decision Quality

Editors are responsible for clearly communicating editorial decisions to authors. Decision letters should be of high quality, synthesizing the reviewers' recommendations and providing additional constructive suggestions. Editors must not simply attach the reviewers' comments without providing a clear explanation and summary of the decision.

  • Corrections and Integrity

If an editor receives convincing evidence that an unpublished article contains significant errors or false concepts, they must inform the author and initiate a procedure to address the issue. If a published article is found to contain such errors, the editor must promptly pursue corrective action, which may include issuing a correction, retracting the article, or publishing an expression of concern, and must clearly communicate this to readers.

  • Authority

The Editor-in-Chief holds ultimate authority and responsibility for the journal's content. They must respect all stakeholders—including readers, authors, reviewers, and editorial staff—and work to ensure the journal's content is truthful, honest, and continuously improving. The Editor is responsible for selecting editorial board members based on a written assessment, clearly defining their roles, and evaluating their performance regularly.

  • Journal Management and Operations

The Editor should manage the journal's operations with attention to all relevant aspects, including policy, technical, financial, and managerial considerations. The journal's performance will be evaluated annually based on metrics such as submission volume, acceptance rate, publication intervals, and the percentage of articles sent for international peer review. These operational indexes should be used to assess the efficiency of the editorial process and drive continuous improvement.

         3-Responsibility of Reviewers

  • Purpose of Peer-Review
    The primary purpose of peer review is to assist the editor and editorial board in making publishing decisions. A secondary, yet vital, purpose is to help the author improve the quality of their submission.
  • Promptness
    Reviewers should only accept an invitation to review if they are qualified to assess the manuscript and can return their assessment within the timeframe specified by the editor. If they cannot meet these conditions, they should promptly withdraw from the process.
  • Confidentiality
    Manuscripts under review are confidential documents. Reviewers must not discuss them with anyone or use any information from them without the explicit approval of the editor.
  • Disclosure and Conflicts of Interest
    Reviewers must decline to review any manuscript in which they have a conflict of interest arising from competitive, collaborative, financial, organizational, or personal relationships with any authors, companies, or institutions connected to the work.If a reviewer becomes aware of a potential conflict of interest—such as editing a very similar paper elsewhere—they must disclose it to the editor, who will determine the appropriate course of action. While the double-blind process is designed to prevent reviewers from knowing authors' identities, if a reviewer becomes aware of the author's identity and a conflict exists, they must inform the editor. Editors and editorial board members will recuse themselves from handling manuscripts where such conflicts exist and will not use unpublished information from a submission for their own research.
  • Standards of Objectivity
    Reviews must be objective and constructive. Assessments should be based on the work's scientific merit and supported by evidence and reasoned argument. Personal criticism of the author is inappropriate.
  • Acknowledgment of Sources
    Reviewers should identify relevant published work that the authors have not cited. Any claim that an observation or argument has been previously reported must be accompanied by the appropriate citation. Reviewers must also alert the editor to any substantial similarity or overlap between the manuscript under consideration and any other published paper of which they are aware.
  • Reciprocity
    Peer review is a cornerstone of academic professionalism. Researchers who benefit from the process by submitting their work are expected to contribute to it by accepting requests to review for the journal when possible.
  • Right to Decline
    Reviewers have the right and responsibility to decline a review request if they feel unqualified, face a conflict of interest, or cannot meet the deadline. If asked to review a manuscript they have previously assessed for another journal, they should inform the editor of this fact.
  • Double-Blind Peer-Review
    This journal employs a double-blind peer-review process. Reviewers must make every effort to preserve anonymity. They should not inform the author of their identity and must not seek to discover the author's identity.
  • Professionalism and Impartiality
    Reviewers must evaluate manuscripts objectively, fairly, and professionally, avoiding any personal or professional biases.
  • Precision and Clarity
    Reviewers should provide clear, thorough, and well-supported feedback. Their comments should be honest and consistent, providing the editor with a justified rationale for their recommendation and giving the author actionable advice for improvement.
  • Punctuality
    Reviewers are expected to submit their assessment by the agreed deadline. If a reviewer anticipates a significant delay (typically beyond one month), they must immediately contact the editor to either negotiate an extension or decline the invitation so a new reviewer can be found.

       4-Copyright and License

  • License
    The journal of the Crisis Studies of the Islamic World( (CSIW) is a fully open-access journal. All articles are made available immediately upon publication under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0 International (CC-BY 4.0) license. Licensees are permitted to copy, distribute, display, and create derivative works, provided that the original published article is properly cited.

 

  • Copyright

Authors retain copyright and transfer commercial rights to the publisher.

The authors have all rights to use the copy in their educational activities, their websites, the websites of the institution or the funder, providing a full reference to the final version published in this publication.

Authors may use the final published article for their professional, occupational or professional purposes by citing the publication of the journal.   If copyright infringement or plagiarism is identified at any stage—from review to evaluation, or even after acceptance and publication—it will be publicly disclosed on the journal's website. The case will also be reported to the disciplinary committee of the corresponding author's university or other legally competent authorities.

  • Originality Check: The journal employs matching software and authentic scientific databases to verify the originality of submitted works.
  • Similarity  should be less than 15%. This journal uses the Samim Noor Similarity Check System to find similarities.
  1. Informed Consent
    For research involving human participants, authors must uphold the right to privacy. Identifying information (e.g., names, initials, photographs) must not be published without written informed consent from the participant (or their parent/guardian). Consent is only justified if the identifying information is essential for scientific purposes.

Informed consent for publication requires that any identifiable participant be shown the manuscript before publication. Authors must disclose to participants that identifiable material may be available both online and in print. The written consent must be archived with the journal, the authors, or both, in accordance with local regulations and laws.

  1. Plagiarism Policy
    The journalof Crisis Studies of the Islamic World ( (CSIW)adheres to the codes of conduct and best practice guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). We regard plagiarism as a serious breach of publishing ethics.

Authors must submit original works. When the work or ideas of others are used, they must be appropriately cited or referenced. The following constitutes unacceptable plagiarism:

  • Verbatim copying or paraphrasing of substantial parts of another's work without attribution.
  • Claiming results from research conducted by others.
  • Submitting a manuscript that is a compilation of previously published material without original authorial interpretation.

Authors must ensure their manuscript:

  • Describes original work.
  • Is free of plagiarism.
  • Has not been previously published in any language.
  • Properly cites and references all used information and words from other publications.

Copyright laws must be observed; permission is required to reproduce copyrighted material (e.g., tables, figures, large quotations). The editorial board reserves the right to screen all submissions for plagiarism. Manuscripts with a overall similarity index of 15% or higher will be rejected. Furthermore, the similarity from any single source must not exceed 2%.

 

  1. Policy on Screening for Plagiarism
    All submitted manuscripts must be free of plagiarized content. Authors shallperform similarity checks using plagiarism detection software prior to submission.

If plagiarism is detected:

  • The editorial board will notify the authors and request an explanation and necessary amendments.
  • If the authors do not respond satisfactorily within a reasonable timeframe, the manuscript will be rejected, and the authors may be barred from submitting to the journal for 5 years.
  • For serious ethical concerns, the journal will follow COPE's guidelines to address the issue.
  • Definition of Plagiarism
    Plagiarism is the act of using others’ published or unpublished ideas, words, or other intellectual property without appropriate attribution or permission, and presenting them as new and original. The intent and effect are to mislead the reader regarding the contributions of the plagiarizer. This applies to content taken from any source, including abstracts, grant applications, institutional review board applications, or any unpublished or published manuscripts in print or electronic form. Plagiarism is a form of scientific misconduct.
  • Direct Plagiarism:The verbatim copying of text without citation.
  • Mosaic Plagiarism (or Paraphrasing Plagiarism):Borrowing ideas and opinions from an original source and using a few verbatim words or phrases without crediting the author.
  • Self-Plagiarism:The practice of an author reusing significant portions of their own previously published work without formal citation. While sometimes unintentional, it may violate copyright and mislead readers about the novelty of the work. The journal's specific policy on self-plagiarism is stated below.
  • Author Responsibilities
    Authors bear full responsibility for the originality and integrity of their submitted work. They must:
  • Ensure the manuscript is original, has not been published previously, and is not under consideration elsewhere.
  • Appropriately cite and quote all sources of information and ideas.
  • Obtain written permission to reproduce any copyrighted material (e.g., figures, tables, photographs, illustrations, data) and include these permissions upon submission. All necessary acknowledgments must be added to the manuscript.
  • Procedure for Reporting Plagiarism
    To report suspected plagiarism, follow these steps:
  • Inform the editor of the journal where the plagiarized article was published.
  • Provide the original and the plagiarized articles, with the plagiarized sections clearly highlighted.
  • If the evidence is convincing, the editor will initiate a disciplinary review.
  • The editor will contact the editor of the journal that published the original work to rectify the matter.
  • The author accused of plagiarism will be asked to provide a formal explanation.
  • If the author does not respond within a stipulated time or provides an unsatisfactory explanation, the article will be permanently retracted.
  • The author will be barred from submitting to the journal for a minimum of five years.
  • The head of the author's institution will be notified of the misconduct.
  • Journal Policy and Sanctions
    The journalof Crisis Studies of the Islamic World ( (CSIW) adheres to the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). All manuscripts are screened for plagiarism. The Editor-in-Chief is responsible for reviewing any allegations and will take action based on the severity of the offense:
  • Level 1:Plagiarizing a short sentence or portion of another work without citation.

Action: The authors are given a warning and required to revise the text with proper citation.

  • Level 2:Plagiarizing a significant portion of another work without citation.

Action: Immediate rejection of the manuscript. The authors may be sanctioned from submitting to the journal for a period of time.

  • Level 3:Simultaneous submission of the same manuscript to multiple journals.

Action: Immediate rejection and sanctions as outlined in Level 2.

  • All authorslisted on a manuscript are collectively responsible for its content and will be subject to the same sanctions if plagiarism is found.

For cases not covered above or in cases of repeated offenses, the Editorial Board will act according to COPE guidelines and internal policy.

  • Indicators of Plagiarism
    Authors should be aware of the following common indicators of plagiarism:
  • Verbatim Copying:Repeating words, sentences, or paragraphs from another source without quotation marks and citation.
  • Substantial Reproduction:Reproducing the core ideas, research, or creative work of another author without acknowledgment, potentially eliminating the original author's rights.
  • Inadequate Paraphrasing:Paraphrasing ideas, words, or phrases from a source without citing the original author. This is a form of intellectual theft, even if it evades detection by software.
  1. Responding to Allegations of Possible Misconduct
  • Definitions of Misconduct
    Misconduct involves deception, which may be deliberate, a result of reckless disregard for consequences, or due to willful ignorance. As the core goal is to deliberately deceive, the journal's investigation considers both the act and the apparent intent of the individual involved. Unintentional errors are not considered misconduct.

The most common forms of scientific misconduct include:

  • Falsification of Data:Ranging from the fabrication of data to the deceptive selective reporting of findings, omission of conflicting data, or willful suppression and/or distortion of data.
  • Plagiarism:The appropriation of another's language, ideas, or thoughts without crediting the source and representing them as one's own original work.
  • Improprieties of Authorship:Improper assignment of credit, such as excluding contributors, submitting the same material to multiple publications, including individuals who did not contribute to the work, or submitting multi-authored publications without the consent of all authors.
  • Misappropriation of Ideas:The improper use of novel ideas acquired through privileged channels, such as during the review of grant applications or manuscripts. Wholesale appropriation of such material constitutes misconduct.
  • Violation of Research Practices:Serious deviation from accepted practices in proposing or carrying out research, including improper manipulation of experiments to obtain biased results, deceptive statistical or analytical manipulations, or improper reporting of results.
  • Non-Compliance with Regulations:Serious or substantial, repeated, and willful violations of legislative and regulatory requirements affecting research, including those involving the use of funds, care of animals, human subjects, investigational drugs, or hazardous materials.
  • Inappropriate Behavior in Relation to Misconduct:This includes making unfounded or knowingly false accusations of misconduct, failing to report known or suspected misconduct, withholding or destroying information relevant to an investigation, and retaliating against persons involved in an allegation or investigation. This also includes misrepresenting qualifications, experience, or research accomplishments.

 

  1. Responses to Possible Misconducts
    Allegations of misconduct will be investigated by a committee appointed by the Editor-in-Chief, consisting of editorial board members with relevant expertise. The journal will follow the guidelines and flowcharts provided by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)to ensure a fair and thorough investigation. Appropriate actions will be taken based on the committee's findings and COPE's recommendations.
  2. Open Access Policy
    The journalof Crisis Studies of the Islamic World ( (CSIW) provides immediate open access to its content, supporting the Budapest Open Access Initiative principle that peer-reviewed research literature should be freely available on the public internet.

This means any user may read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to the full texts of articles, crawl them for indexing, or use them for any other lawful purpose without financial, legal, or technical barriers beyond those inherent in internet access itself. All articles are published under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)  license.

Benefits of Open Access for Authors:

  • Retained Copyright:Authors retain copyright to their work.
  • Global Reach:Free access for all users worldwide, maximizing visibility, readership, and impact.
  • Increased Impact:Leads to greater recognition, acceptance, and more frequent citations of published work.
  • Rapid Dissemination:Accelerated publication process ensures research is available without delay.
  • Archiving and Sharing:Authors are encouraged to post pre-prints in institutional repositories and the final published PDF on their websites.
  • Cost-Effectiveness:A single article processing charge ensures lifetime online availability without further fees for readers.
  •  
  1. Data Sharing Policy

The journal of Crisis Studies of the Islamic World ( CSIW)  adopts a Basic Data Sharing Policy. We are committed to fostering an open research landscape by facilitating the reproducibility and verification of research. This includes encouraging authors to share the data, software, algorithms, protocols, methods, and materials underlying their articles, provided this does not violate human subject protection or other valid privacy and security concerns.

  • Policy for Authors
    The journal encourages all authors to archive their data inan appropriate public repository and to include a Data Availability Statement in their manuscript. However, authors of Original Investigation, Case Report, and Special Paper articles are required to:
  • Deposit the de-identified data associated with their manuscript in a repository.
  • Include a Data Availability Statement describing where and how the data can be accessed.
  • Defining Data
    For this policy, "data" refers to the digital materials underlying the manuscript's results. This includes, but is not limited to, spreadsheets, text files, interview recordings/transcripts, images, videos, statistical software output, and computer code/scripts. Authors must deposit at least the minimum data required to reproduce the study's results.
  • Repositories
    Data must be placed in any repository that provides public access and a unique persistent identifier (e.g., a DOI). Suitable options include institutional, general (e.g., Figshare, Zenodo, Dryad), or discipline-specific repositories.
  • Data Availability Statement
    This statement must be placed in the manuscript before the reference list and include:
  • The location (repository name) of the data.
  • A unique identifier (e.g., DOI, accession number, or persistent URL).
  • Any special instructions for accessing the data.
  • Submission Process
    During submission, authors will be asked if a dataset is associated with the manuscript. If yes, they must provide the persistent identifier (e.g., DOI or URL). Datasets are not formally peer-reviewed; authors are solely responsible for their data's integrity and any errors therein.
  • Note on Anonymized Review
    Please remove the Data Availability Statement from the anonymized manuscript submitted for double-blind peer review, as it may reveal author identity.
  • Exceptions
    Exceptions to this policy are granted only in rare cases, such as when data is proprietary or sharing would compromise participant privacy. Confidential data must always be anonymized, and authors should consult their institution’s ethics committee if in doubt. Even when data cannot be shared, a Data Availability Statement explaining the restriction is still required.
  • Example Data Availability Statements:
  • The data associated with this study are available in the Open Science Framework at [DOI/URL].
  • The data supporting this study's findings are openly available in [Repository Name] at [DOI/URL], reference number [number].
  • Due to privacy restrictions, the data supporting this study cannot be made publicly available. They are available from [Entity Name] upon reasonable request.
  • Benefits of Sharing Data:
  • Preservation:Depositing data supports its long-term preservation.
  • Credit:A persistent identifier (e.g., DOI) allows the dataset to be cited, giving researchers proper credit.
  • Discovery:Shared data enables re-use, meta-analysis, and new discoveries.
  • Robustness:Public data improves research transparency, validation, and reproducibility.
  • Translation:Wider data availability supports the practical application of research.
  • CSIWStandardized Data Sharing Tiers:
  • Basic:Encourages data sharing and citation where possible, with a Data Availability Statement.
  • Share upon reasonable request:Authors agree to share data upon a request they deem reasonable.
  • Publicly available:Data is made freely available to the public under a license chosen by the author.
  • Open data:Data is freely available under a license allowing re-use by any third party for any lawful purpose.
  • Open and FAIR:Data is freely available under an open license and meets FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Re-usable) standards.
  •  
  1. Data Citation

Data must be formally cited in the reference list, just like articles, books, and websites. Data citations are appropriate for data in repositories and should be provided in addition to standard in-line citations (e.g., for GenBank codes). The journal follows the format proposed by the Joint Declaration of Data Citation Principles:

Authors; Year; Dataset Title; Data Repository; Version (if any); Persistent Identifier (e.g., DOI).

 


Diagram of guidelines of "COPE" publishing ethics committee in English language


Ethical charter of research of "Ministry of Science, Research and Technology"